Brendan O'Neill: Wenn an Elite-Unis ein Lynchmob tobt
Autos

Brendan O'Neill: Wenn an Elite-Unis ein Lynchmob tobt


Heute Abend ist mal wieder Zeit für ein ausführliches Langzitat eines Artikels, den ich sprachlich und inhaltlich besonders treffend finde:

When you hear the phrase "lynch mob," what image comes to mind? Most of us will probably think of tooth-free rednecks with pitchforks off to find themselves some darker-skinned folks to harass. Or we might cast our minds back to a time when angry, hungry people regularly rounded up eccentric old women, blamed them for causing crop failures and other local calamities, and then had them dunked or burned as witches.

I saw a different kind of lynch mob recently at Columbia University. There wasn’t a pitchfork in sight. No one started a fire. Yet this gathering of self-styled justice enforcers, who were loudly demanding the metaphorical scalp of an individual they suspected of doing something bad, nonetheless had the same scary moral righteousness and disregard for due process as every other lynch mob in history. It’s just that they were better dressed, better educated, far more middle-class than the usual fire-wielding dispensers of mob justice. It was an Ivy League lynch mob.

The gathering took place last week as part of a global student uprising against "rape culture" on campus. In solidarity with Columbia student Emma Sulkowicz, who has been dragging around her mattress for the past two months in protest against Columbia’s failure to expel the male student she claims raped her in 2012, students at Columbia and 130 other universities around the world brought their mattresses out, too, many of them emblazoned with slogans condemning "rape culture."

A self-styled Christ of modern student feminism, only forlornly hauling around her bedding rather than a crucifix, Sulkowicz has become a cause célèbre in progressive circles. She’s featured in borderline fashion shoots for New York magazine, complete with skinny jeans, gorgeous flats, and, of course, cross-like mattress slumped across her back like the weight of the world. She and her backers have been gushingly congratulated by vast swaths of the media for "starting a revolution against campus sexual assault."

There’s only one problem with this depiction of the mattress protest to get a male student thrown out of Columbia as some great liberal, revolutionary strike — the male student in question has not been found guilty of assaulting Sulkowicz. Her alleged assailant (many in the media forget to use the word "alleged") was brought before a disciplinary hearing at Columbia and found "not responsible" for the things Sulkowicz accused him of. Sulkowicz later filed a complaint with the police but, according to the New York Times, "didn’t follow through with the necessary steps to prosecute the student." So, she and her cheerleaders want a student who has not been convicted of assault to be expelled from the university. They want a man to be punished on the word of one accuser, which is surely behavior more befitting a Stalinist tyranny than a liberal-arts college.

At Columbia, I was startled by some of the mob-like invective falling from the mouths of otherwise bright, well-read students. One group of female students said "the rapist" must be expelled. But he hasn’t been found guilty of committing rape, I said. "We know he committed the rape," one said, with the kind of steely-eyed conviction that recalled (admittedly in a much less lethal context) how KKK members once "knew" that their black victims were guilty of raping local white women.

A male student told me my insistence that individuals suspected of a crime must be fairly tried and found convincingly guilty before we ruin their lives — and being expelled from a prestigious university for rape would undoubtedly be life-ruining — was evidence that I had fallen for the "liberal paradigm" of justice, which tends to benefit white, well-off men. Apparently there is another "paradigm," a better one, in which women who accuse men of rape are instantly believed and the men in question swiftly and severely punished.

The speeches made by students from the mattress-strewn steps leading up to the beautiful Low Library were chilling. Many focused on the need to believe women who make accusations. "I believe!" they hollered, to cheers from the crowd. This casual assertion of belief in all accusations of sexual assault mirrors the gullible fanaticism of the 17th-century Salem trials, where, likewise, claims and denunciations were taken at face value. When twelve Boston-based ministers said that the Salem magistrates should not rely so heavily on "spectral evidence" — that is, evidence based on dreams and visions rather than proven facts — they were roundly condemned. And so it is today that anyone who says that a rape allegation should be treated seriously but should not be automatically believed runs the risk of being branded a "rape apologist." It would have been a brave student indeed who stood up at the Salem-like belief-fest at Columbia last week and said, "We have to prove accusations, not naïvely accept them."


Hier geht es weiter mit der zweiten Hälfte des Artikels von Brendan O'Neill, dem Chefredakteur des bekannten liberalen Online-Magazins "Spiked".




Veja Também:

- Rape Culture: Matratzen-feministinnen Demonstrieren Gegen Feministische Professorin
Last Monday, about thirty Northwestern anti-rape activists marched to their school’s administrative center carrying mattresses and pillows. The event was a deliberate echo of the performance art project of Columbia student Emma Sulkowicz, who is lugging...

- Dekan Der Columbia: Auch Beim Matratzenmädel Hätten Journalisten Beide Seiten Hören Sollen
Rolling Stone's hoax story about a brutal gang rape at the University of Virginia is not the only example of poor journalism when it comes to reporting on campus sexual assault. Sheila Coronel, Columbia University's dean of academic affairs,...

- Er Wird Vom Campus Verwiesen, Weil Sie Sex Von Ihm Wollte
A student is suing Occidental College in Los Angeles for expelling him after a female student allegedly sent text messages indicating she had wanted to have sex, arranged for a rendezvous, then one week later accused him of sexual assault. The case is...

- Student An Der Columbia: "ich Habe Sie Nicht Vergewaltigt"
The Columbia University senior vividly remembers the day, in April 2012, when he received a phone call while working in the school’s digital architecture lab. It was the campus Office of Gender-Based and Sexual Misconduct, asking him to come in to talk....

- "es Ist Zeit, Die Matratze Niederzulegen"
Naomi Schaeffer Riley kommentiert das neuste Debakel in der feministischen Propgandaschlacht um eine sogenannte "Rape Culture" in der New York Post. Ein Auszug: Whatever else you can say about social media these days, it has made it awfully hard for...



Veja mais em: Autos







.